Elaine Rebori has transcribed a index for this cemetery from church records.
| Last Name | First Name | Maiden Name | Birth Date | Death Date | Age | Source | Remarks | Contact |
| Coffin | William H. | 15-Mar-1857 in Indiana | 1915 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | |||
| Coffin | Sybil Jane | Small | 05-Nov-1860 in Carmel Indiana | 14-Jun-1945 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | ||
| Coffin | Drusilla | 28-Apr-1879 in Carmel Indiana | 1976 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | |||
| Coffin | Herbert | 1889 | 1892 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | |||
| Coffin | Maude | 1888 | 1888 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | |||
| Courtney | Anna | 14-Mar-1865 | 10-Feb-1943 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Charles E. | 1892 | 1954 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Charles F., Dr | 26-Jan-1852 | 30-Jun-1903 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Elizabeth | 1859 | 1938 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | India Russel | 1863 | 24-Nov-1888 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Lena | 1892 | 1930 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Luna | 1892 | 1913 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Marcissa | 10-Dec-1831 | 28-May-1924 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Robert E. | 13-Dec-1827 | 15-Dec-1915 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Rufus | 1853 | 1925 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | Thomas | 04-Jun-1866 | 06-Sep-1902 | Headstone | ||||
| Courtney | William A. | 1904 | 1904 | Headstone | ||||
| Small | James G. | 1828 in Indiana | 1912 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori | |||
| Small | Anna | Wilson | 1834 in Indiana | 1911 | Elaine Rebori | Donated by Elaine Rebori |